The Municipality of Anchorage has entered a $60,000 settlement with a man who claimed that local police harassed him, during a gunpoint arrest in the aftermath of a 2010 shooting at a Downtown Anchorage bar.
According to a copy of the settlement provided by City Attorney Dennis Wheeler, in addition to writing Matt Newman a check, all APD patrol officers will receive two to four hours of training in verbal communication and de-escalation by Dec. 31.
In an email accompanying the settlement's text, Wheeler says that the city sometimes settles cases based on the costs of defending itself, rather than on the merits of the case.
"The Municipality and the plaintiff engaged in a settlement process which resulted in both sides giving ground as to their positions, resulting in a resolution of the case," Wheeler wrote. "The plaintiff claimed over $450,000 in damages. The Municipality paid the plaintiff $60,000, to include his attorney fees and costs."
Police reports from the early hours of Sept. 12, 2010 say the incident involving Norman occurred at about 1:30 a.m. -- roughly half an hour after 21-year-old Mavaega Brandon Tautua opened fire outside the now-closed Rumrunners Old Towne Bar and Grill at 415 E St., wounding Angel Martin-Laura, 19, and Shawna Calt, 27.
Ofc. Charles Lochart III wrote that he and Ofc. Bradley Braeger had been securing the scene of the shooting when Newman approached and tried to walk past him.
"Ofc. Breager and I stepped in front of him and explained that the area was a crime scene and directed him to cross the street," Lochart wrote. "Newman was immediately hostile and belligerent, and refused to comply. It was only after we ordered him several times to the other side of the street that he complied."
Lochart says Newman soon began to complain to Sgt. Julie Shank and Ofc. Ryan Rockom that a friend's car was within the crime scene.
"As Sgt. Shank was explaining to him that the car was in the crime scene and couldn't be moved at that time, Newman kept yelling over her," Lochart wrote. "He was yelling profanities and refused to disperse, though Ofc. Rockom ordered him to leave several times or face arrest."
At that point Lochart moved in behind Newman, with Rockom announcing that he was under arrest. Newman twisted his arms out of the officers' hands when they tried to seize him, running west along 4th Avenue to the nearby Sunshine Plaza mall. Lochart, Rockom and Ofc. Patrick Gilbert were among those who pursued Newman, as he ran down one flight of stairs and then up another.
"We continued to chase him up the stairs," Lochart wrote. "Upon reaching the top Newman was confronted at gunpoint by Ofc. Gilbert who was blocking his passage."
According to Lochart, Newman sat down on the top step of the staircase, refusing to lie prone despite Rockom aiming a Taser at him, then pulling him down from behind.
"Newman refused to surrender his arms for handcuffing and was holding them underneath him," Lochart wrote. "I punched Newman in the left side of his ribs in an attempt to dislodge his left arm. Eventually we were able to place Newman under arrest after a short struggle."
Newman was taken into custody and remanded to the Anchorage Jail, on charges of disorderly conduct and resisting arrest.
Tautua, the suspect in the shooting, was sentenced in May 2011 to serve 12 years in prison for two counts of first-degree assault and one count of third-degree misconduct involving a weapon.
Contact Chris Klint